Myogenic trigger point - generator of pathologic sensomotor system
Prof. Ivanichev G.A
Kazan, Russia
The miogenic trigger points (MTP) are not a separate nosologic
unit. Though they are frequently found in the clinical manifestations
of variouns (not only neurologic) pathology there is no unanimity in
understandig of the essence, pathogenesis and terminologic
identification. There are more than 25 names which give different names
to one and the same state of the muscle. The name - myogenic trigger
point was chosen in order to achive mutual understandig among the
representatives of different medical specialities. It is correct from
the view-point of neurophysiology and neuropathology.
The participation of MTP in pathomorphism of the basic neurologic
pathology has not been studied up till now. It was due to the
simplified conception of the MTP pathogenesis as a mere local
distonically dystrophic process.
The aim of our work was to study the clinical and neurophysiologic
MTP characteristics in different structural lesions of the nervous
system as well as the substantiation of MTP pathogenesis and the
development of adequate methods of treatment.
Analysis of clinico-electrophysiological MTP characteristics was
necessary under the following conditions:
1) absence of the nervous system disturbance;
2) nervous system disturbance in the efferent and afferent links;
3) affection of the central mechanisms of motor regulation.
Material and methods. According to 10 year studies there were 120 patients with MTP, 80
patients with facial nerve neuropathy, 58 - with syringomyelia, 50 -
with spastik torticollis. Patients with MTP had no disturbances of the
nervous system and the spinal cord neither systemic muscle diseases -
"pure" MTP. In the group of 15 patients with neuropathy of facial
nerves the development of contracture was estimated from paresis to
contracture, the state of mimic muscles was estimated regularly during
the pathologic process. In patients with algetic syringomyelia there
were no arthropathies, myorrhexis and other vegeto-trophic disorders.
Patients with spastic torticollis had tonic and tonico-clonic
hyperkinesia, there were no MTP in the clonic form.
Investigation methods included kinetic palpation of the skeletal
muscles according to the traditional method by Marsov.
1) Facial muscle palpation was estimated according to the original
method of G.Ivanichev,1984.
2) The firmness of muscless was estimated by registration of the
deformity pressing it using the external alternating exertion, randing
from 1,0 to 5,0 kg/cm.
Electrophysiologic studies included:
1) Electromyography by the superficial and needle electrodes with
presented histogram of the PMUA (potentials of motor units action)
distribution in the MTP centre and periphery.
2) Registration of polysynaptic reflex reactions and the phenomenon of
voluntary activity inhibition.
3) Estimation of muscle reciprocal relations-antagonists having MTP.
4) Determination of contration wave rate throughout the muscle.
5) Determination of the muscle differential stimulation when muscle
being irritated with stimuli of varions duration and intensity.
6) Determination of the frequency of potential movement in the MTP
centre and periphery.
Results. MTP in the basic group.
The basic MTP clinic characteristics should be called the local
induration of a muscle of different size, the local reflex pain
(trigger phenomenon), increase of tenderness in passive muscle
stretching as well as increased mechanical stimulation. The MTP
localisazion in the skeletal muscle as compared to the data presented
by T.Travell given in the book written with D.Simons as co author.
Accordind to our understanding the phenomenon of the reflex pain
is a rather changeable clinical parametr both from view - point of
intensity and direction. The phenomenon depends on the patient's
emotional background and the initial muscle state. Thus following
dynamic work of MTP muscle the spectrum of the reflex pain has entirely
different characteristics than after the performance of the static
work. The different picture of reflex pain is observed when it is
induced by pressure or by stretching as well. It is worth mentioning
that the maximum pain is abundant in the first seconds. Then due to
adoptation the pain is localized and seems to be the secondary pains.
The MTP magnitude and the extent of tenderness are incomparable
indices. MTP division according to their magnitude to Cornellius',
Muller's nodules, to Shade's, Lange's myogelosis have no practical
sense.
In this paper we do not present the deseriptive characteristics of
MTP localisazion in the different muscles. This section is kery well
described in T.Travell's and D.Simon's book (1984). We should like to
point here that MTP may occur in any muscle. In the structure of one
muscle MTP may occur in any part but predoninantly they ara localized
in the thickest (strongest) part. The most characteristic feature of
hypertonicity is a significant rise in tenderness during muscle
stretching. The diagnostic value of this test is perfect, it is better
than the phenomenon of vibration response /reproduction of pain picture
during energetic beating/. Rise in tenderness pain that is familiar to
the patient and its disappearance after brief resistance of mild
intensity is typical of MTP. During further stretching of the muscle
MTP tenderness is again increasing to a certain degres with the
following decrease when the brief efforts are resumed. This method is
based on the MTP postisometric relaxation /K.Lewit, 1982/. This
diagnosis may be called therapeutic diagnostics which may be of use not
only in neurology.
Changes in bioelectric MTP activity in electromyography using
surface electrodes have not been detected. The expected high EMG
activity corresponding to the degree of tenderness was not evident. In
response to the needle electrode insertion into the MTP - the
bioelectric activity is followed by plunding potencials and by a
complex of discharges different in their form and duration. There are
polyphase /up to 30%/ and positive sharp waves along with the
fibrillation potential. The duration of this activity is from several
seconds /to one minute/. Then at rest bioelectrical activity is not
detected. During voluntary tension the amplitude of potentials of MTP
is lower by 25-35% than in the adjacent area. During a passive
stretching of the muscle there is a significant increase in the
activity and it is almost equal to the bioelectrical activity of the
voluntary effort. The comparison of MTP in the centre and in the
periphery showed some significant differences. If EMG activity of the
centre seemed to be low, with small amplitude and its quick reduction
(fall), then in the periphery of hypertonicity all indicated parameters
are detected in the other quantitative and qualitative ratio.
Apparently, the constant muscle stretching of the transitional zone is
evidently originated on the border of MTP periphery and the normal
muscle which produces EMG "anxiety" even of rest, particularly during a
mild muscle sretching.
Such distibution in durations is characteristic for the distorted
spatial relations of MU of the terminals not resulting from the
denervation processes but the distorded architectonics of the muscle
with MTP.
The velosity of wave stimulation transfer through MTP is
considerably reduced. This change
cannot but probably influence on biomechanics of the muscle
contraction. This is manifested dy the destruction of reciprocal
relatios of the muscles if one of them has MTP. Electromyographic
assessment of the dynamic load (50 complete flexions and extentions of
the hand with increased speed showed a change in EMG structure. In the
presence of MTP in the general extensor of the hand at the moment of
flexor contraction of the hand the extensors are not sufficiently
relaxed. During extensor contraction EMG of the contractive activity
occurs. THe distrubance of the spinal cord segmental apparatus
activity is found using registration of polysynaptic reflex responses
and muscle voluntary activity inhibition.
The characteristic feature of MTP must be considered depressed
inhibition of bioelectic activity - "silence phenomenon" - absence in
the MTP area.
Myogenic trigger point in clinical manifestations of contracture
of mimic muscles /motor neuron affection/.
Hypertonicities of mimic muscles are formed in at extent of the
facial nerve affection. During the mild nerve affection they disappear
as the muscle function are restored, in severe they disappear together
with the affected musculature. In avarage neuropathy hypertonicities
undergo a pathalogic course. The main symptom of contracture -
spasm-paresis occurs on 25-30 days. When contracture is complete MTP
are found in any mimic muscle, their localization is sufficiently
typical. Both elongated and shortened potencials are found in
hypertinicities by electromyography when contracture has been formed.
This combination of durations evidently indicates the spatial change of
the motor unit terminals in mimic musculature denervation. We consider
some "stamped" positive potencials of 15-18 ms duration to be a
specific EMG feature, they are found in the zones of junction of
different muscle groups. As evidenced by Lambert and B.M.Gekht
these potencials are a sigh of intermuscular impulse transmission. To
prove the hypothesis of an "artificial synapse" we have presented the
method of consecutive ortho antidromic stimulation of the distal
branches, of the facial nerve in the region of eye angle and mouth
/G.Ivanichev/. The possibility of interneural impulse transmission in
the zone of affection /Waltman and co-worcers, 1956/ has not been
proved by us.
Thus, MTP become the site of intermuscles transmission of motor
impulses that is aphatic intermuscular transmission when the muscles
are denervated partially.
Miogenic trigger point in clinical manifestations of algesic syringomyelia
/afferent neuron affection/.
Analysis of the clinical picture of algesic syringomyelia
indicated that the 75% tenderness of soft tissues and muscles first of
all in the analgesia zone is due to MTP but not to irritative processes
in the posterior horn of the spinal cord. The role of irritative
reactions is known to be suggested by Schlesinger. Our data
confirm K.Lewits view-point who was the first to assume the
existence of pains in syringomyelia to be due to the functional
blockades of the spinal joints and to the concomitant muscle spasms.
The electromyographic picture of MTP in algesic syringomyelia has no
essential differences from MTP of general origin. Thus MTP can be
formed when afferent neuron is affected.
Miogenic trigger point in clinical manifestations of spastic torticollis
/central mechanism affection in tonus regulation/.
MTP are revealed only in the tonic form of torticollis are more
coarse than the "usual". They are detected against the background of
the tense muscle as a considerable indurations. The long tonic spasm of
the neck muscle rotators produces the combined coarse fuctional blocade
of the cervical vertebto-motor segments.
The most vulnerable levels are the cranio-cervical transition and
mid cervical segments. These mechanisms underlie a stable pathologic
dynamic stereotype which can support the head faulty posture without
pathologic affect on the central mechanisms. In this sense the
peripheric pathologic mechanism of torticollis (MTP plus articular
blockades) has a far higher pathologic activity than the central
structural tonus regulations.
The regularity of polysynaptic reflexes manifestations in the
tonically strained muscles is rudely distorted. There was no
bioelectric activity inhibition of the strained muscles when the
polysinaptic reflexes were produced.
The study of the cerebral blood flow showed the essential
disturbance of hemodynamics in patients with torticollis. These
disturbances are detected in the vertebro-arterial system: the blood
flow is the poorest one on the side opposite to the head turn. This
pathologic hemodynamics is due to a stable cervical musculature tension
and to the change of the main vessels tonus.
Thus MTP in spastic torticollis are detected against the
background of the previously tonically strained musculature of the
neck, finally forming a complex system of active peripheral
pathogenetic factor.
Pathogenesis of myogenic trigger point. The trigger moment
of MTP development is static /isometric/ work
of the muscle with minimal intensity within a long period of time. This
kind of work may be due to the reflex tension of the muscle in the
pathology of an internal organ, functional blocades of joints etc. The
space deformation of the working muscle occurs during prolonged static
work. The most strong, the more active part from view-point of
innervation streches the most thin and weak one /Beritov I.S., 1947/.
When the tension is off this deformity disappers due to the natural
muscle elasticity. During continuous static work of the muscle the
induced deformity produces the next stage of the pathologic changes.
First of all this is the distortion of proprioceptive afferentation due
to the spatial reorganization of the receptors. The main tendency of
afferent disorganization is the disbalance of impulses of the dynamic
and static madality. This pathologic situation is responsible for the
following changes in the activity of the segmental apparatus of the
spinal cord.
1) The disorder of the presynaptic inhibition mechanisms providing
"gate control" at aditis medulla spinalis. As a result the primary
pattern of nociceptive impulsation is formed which corresponds to the
muscle hypertonicity.
2) The disturbance of the motor neuron impulse activity. As a
result a territorial change of the motor unit, distortion of
coordinative relations, muscular contraction rate delay, descrease of
strength occur.
3) The disturbance of non impulsive activity /neurotrophic
control/. This is evidenced by the muscle metabolism change and the
development of dystrophic processes in it.
The pathologic changes in the activity of the segmental apparatus
are the basis of pathologic alterations, regulating the suprasegmental
structure influence. This means the change in the program motion that
is the formation of the pathologic dynamic stereotypes. These changes
may provide varions emotional stresses in MTP that is a personal
estimation of the tenderness and other MTP manifestations. As a result
of these complicated changes uniting the periphery, segmental
apparatus, the suprasegmental structures, a stable pathologic
sensomotor system is formed , MTP being its generator. In mimic
musculature contraction the development of the muscle hypertonicities
occurs according to another schema.
The main stages are:
1. At any extent of facial nerve affection hypertonicities in the
muscles are formed on the 3-4 day according to Vulpian's tonomotor
effect. In the mild nerve affection these hypertonicities dysappear as
the muscles are regenerating while in severe - they disappear together
with degenerative muscle.
2. At the average extent of affection hypertonicities have a
chance for further development - they bring together different muscle
bundles, they cause the deformity of the receptor apparatus. As a
result there is a possibility of intermuscular transmission of
impulses. Pathologic sinkinesias of different muscles are explained by
this pathologic intermuscular synapse. The disbalance of proprioception
is also a base of formation of the pathologic sensomotor system
"trigeminal-facial nerve" with the secondary involvement of the
limbicoreticular system.
The details of this process were presented in monography by
G.Ivanitchev (1992).
Treatment of myogenic trigger point. It includes a complex of therapeutic measures in order to
eliminate the distruction of the pathologic sensomotor system. First it
must eliminate MTP (pressure, extension, postisometric relaxation,
irrigation). Second, normalization of the activity of the spinal cord
segmental apparatus - physiotherapeutic procedures, drugs, acupuncture.
Third normalization of suprasegmental influence on the motor activity
and sensor systems, physical training, treatment of psychic disorders.