Pathogenesis of myogenic trigger points
Prof. Ivanichev G.A
Kazan, Russia
Any kind of stimulation which directly or through a reflex is
able to initiate muscle contractions resulting in a motor act. The
completion of the accomodative process of muscle contraction implies
muscle relaxation producing this effect. This occurs under conditions
similar to the ideal ones. More often the muscle activity cannot be
characterized as accomodative. A prolonged muscular tension in
chronic pain is a convincing example to that. The signal essence of
pain in the following stages of the disease is characterized by
pathologic features while a prolonged contraction turns out to be a
dialectical converse.
Let us consider some steps of the formation of the local
muscular tension.
The initial stage is a residual muscular tension. The trigger
moment of a Myogenic trigger point (M.T.P.) is a static (isometric)
work with minimal intensity during a long period of time. This kind
of work is due to a reflex muscular tension in inner organ pathology
(defans), spine disturbance (immobilization of the destructed
segment), cold effect on the skin (reflex tension), defective motor
stereotype (overload of some separate muscular groups) etc. In
contrast to the dynamic work, the static work is known to have its
own characteristics. First and foremost it is a very small range of
physiological functions. From the point of view of phylogenetics the
dynamic work may be more perfect: physiologic adaptation measures are
more dynamic, there is a profitable energy supply. The lability of
the neuromotor system, proprioceptive afferentation, coordinating
relations - are prerequisites for any muscle contraction.
A simple analysis indicates that all these indices have been
historically evolved to become more and more perfect. Otherwise the
static muscle work would perform posture activity in posture support,
while the dynamic one has a precise, prompt, transitory activity,
connected with the reaction of choice. The ways how these moments are
organized are principally different. Tough, determining (circular
type of organization according to N.A.Bernstein, (1947) is primarily
responsible for the static kind of activity. It is due to functional
organization of the spinal-segmental apparatus. Less tough, more
changeable (a programmed N.A.Bernstein's type) provides a supraspinal
control of predominantly dynamic activity of the neuromotor system.
The latter type is more liable in motor control.
Hence, there occurs in long term static work with minimal
intensity a complicated change in the functional activity of the
corresponding neuromotor system. Mostly it is a space deformation of
the working muscle. The most thick and strong portion of the muscle
stretches the most thin and weak one, which is a well known
physiological phenomenon (I.S.Beritov, 1947). On release from tension
this deformity disappears due to a natural muscle elasticity; muscle
relaxation is known to be a passive act due to its physico-chemical
properties and the antagonist state. The period of relaxation is used
for muscle rest (restoration of energy reserve, lability, inhibition
systems etc.). This is just a physiologic measure of adoptation of
the motor apparatus under natural activity conditions.
During a prolonged work though of minimum intensity, the
reserved potentialities, especially during a transient interval have
not enough time to supply the initial physiologic parameters of the
motor substratum. The residual tension - a formed space deformation
of the muscle portion in its weak part - is preserved. While the
static work is going on under the above regimen this deformation is
increasing as a result of accumulation of all changes. Indeed, this
process may be local only for a short period of time.
Conditions for neuromotor system activity naturally involve the
segmental-spinal mechanisms. Probably, they are aimed at repairing of
physiologic and morphologic parameters of this muscle. Depletion of
the restoration resources of the initial state implies inclusion of
mechanisms whose effect should be regarded as being pathological.
This process is thought to begin as an impaired proprioceptive
impulsation on the border of a muscle region with a residual
deformation and normal structure. It is natural to admit that this
region is the most tense from the point of view of morphologic
orientation of the muscle and afferent innervation under all other
conditions of the functional state. The receptor apparatus in this
zone may turn out to be under complicated conditions of functioning -
overstretching of the portion of the neuromuscular spindle (as a
linear substratum) during some relative compression of another
portion. This induces diversely directed deformation of the receptors
which belong to one and the same afferent fibre. Therefore sensor
impulsation would occur under conditions different from normal.
The main tendency of afferent imbalance implies an imbalance of
dynamic and static modality impulsation. This suggestion is confirmed
by studying the relationship between the bioelectrical activity of
the muscle while evoking the tonic vibration reflex (static activity
imitation of the proprioreceptors) and in muscle stretching (dynamic
activity imitation). If 2 min. vibration of a muscle with M.T.P. does
not substantially change the level of the muscle bioelectrical
activity than its even transient stretching sharply intensifies it -
much more than the stretching of a normal "healthy" muscle.
Inadequate impulsation overcoming the control at the input into
segmentary apparatus is able to bomb the anterior horn motoneurons as
a result of its continuation, producing the appropriate changes in
them.
Efferent impulsation supported by a prolonged afferent
stimulation through group Ia afferents is able in its turn to
aggravate the local space changes of the muscle architectonics.
Probably, the segment interneuron activity, reverse inhibition
included is characterized by the reduction of effectiveness of the
inhibitory processes. It is through this the way is "ushered" of the
proprioceptive constant reflex, which has unequivocal pathologic
meaning in the muscle activity. Impairment of the architectonics
terminals of the motor units in the hypertonicity zone (space
aberration) is the result of this pathologic reflex and the reason
why the subsequent space changes of the muscular band - fascicule
occur.
To regard the spinal-segmental and local mechanisms as just
being pathological ones means a mere simplification of the above
mentioned complicated processes. The problem is complicated not only
because the involved structures are multicomponent and because the
relationship of the phenomena should be determined, but because all
these processes are greatly influenced by the supra-segmental
structures. The study of the functional state of these bands under
clinical conditions is known to be rather difficult from the
methodical point of view. All kinds of assessment of monosynaptic
reflex (H-reflex), plantar response of lumbar motoneurons (F-wave),
M-response, so far employed fail to bring solution to the problem
under study. What seems to be promising in this respect is the method
of investigation into the evoked responses manifested by long reflex
relations, e.g. the evoked sensor potentials of different brain
structures (L.P.Zenkov, M.A. Ronkin, 1982; L.P.Zenkov, 1984). Though
this technique seems to be very attractive still the evoked cerebral
cortex potentials cannot provide an exhaustive study of M.T.P.
pathogenesis.
For our studies we needed a technique of registration of evoked
responses of muscular fibers themselves. This approach could be made
by development of a new technique of evoking a spinal-truncal
polysynaptic reflex (STPR). The mechanism of reflex implies
motoneuron discharge production in the spinal cord during irritation
of the mixed nerve of the upper extremity (median or ulnar).
The response is registered as a polysynaptic discharge 40 - 60 ms
long with the latent period of 60 - 150 ms. Such information about
the reflex nature was given in our publications (G.I.Ivanichev, 1983,
1985).
Let us notify the characteristic manifestations of this reflex
which are necessary for understanding of the nature of M.T.P.
pathogenesis. One of the features of STPR is that the STPR latent
period has a lot of fluctuations due to a characteristic
manifestation of the pain syndrome in the registration region. In
pronounced tenderness of the soft tissues the STPR latent period is
reduced, and the duration of the discharge is quite varied. As
tenderness diminishes the STPR latent time increases due to compact
response.
Another peculiarity is that STPR has a refractory period due to
delay which is the result of activation of the truncal structures. In
mild voluntary contractions of muscles where STPR is studied the
above reflex is detected quite often, i.e. some relief is achieved.
In strong muscular contractions STPR is naturally produced too but
only when there is a significant bioelectrical activity which makes
it hard to identify it. The so called period of inhibition of the
bioelectrical activity makes the task easier. It follows the produced
STPR. This period is clearly seen on the electromyogram, it
corresponds to the end of the reflex discharge front. The earlier
assumptions about the segmental origin of the inhibitory period due
to the activity of the segmental apparatus of the spinal cord
(P.Shahani, R.Yung, 1973; I.A.Zavalishin, V.P.Novikova, 1979;
R.S.Person, 1985) were not confirmed.
This information is due to findings obtained from STPR which
made it possible to observe at least one way of regulation of the
activity of the spinal segmental apparatus. Probably it has a
physiological nature in producing posture motor reactions. This point
of view is confirmed by clinical examples observed- models of
structural impairment of the nervous system when STPR is distorted or
disappears altogether.
Using this method of STPR study it was possible to make an
impression on the disturbance of its manifestation in myofascicular
hypertonisity - M.T.P. Thus, dispersion of the latent time (period)
and the response duration in M.T.P. is rather significant as compared
to that in the region of a normal muscle or on the border between
them. One of the most obvious features of pathological manifestation
of STPR, one should consider the STPR inhibitory failure in M.T.P
center. This disorder in inhibition may be complete and may be not,
i.e. some responses cannot be inhibited. These data serve as an
electrophysiologic evidence of participation of suprasegmental
structures in M.T.P. pathogenesis. The assumption about it becomes
rather convincing from the point of view of pains which become more
intense in neurotic states and psychovegetative syndroms. Functional
changes in the limbicoreticular complex are known to influence
significantly on the tonic muscular activity (A.M.Vein, V.S.Maltsina,
1974). Disfunction of these sections accompanied by the concurrent
changes in regulation of the neuromotor activity of the subordinate
systems is a component of M.T.P. pathogenesis. Obviously this system
exerts the most significant effect on the subjective assessment of
M.T.P. tenderness. Very often this part of clinical manifestations is
from the patient's point of view most essential: M.T.P. appearance is
connected with an episode of psychoemotional stress, long-term stress
situations. In this respect M.T.P. manifestations may be evidenced
psychoemotionally.
Obviously, all systems of motor regulation are manifested in
M.T.P. pathogenesis. A variety of the functional levels evidenced in
M.T.P. pathogenesis makes it possible to consider the local elevation
of muscular tonisity as a sign of the posture basic activity under
pathologic conditions. In a strict sense of hierarchic subordination
M.T.P. pathogenesis must have occurred with the participation of
cortex prefrontal region. However, the clinical and
electrophysiological techniques of examination offer no help to prove
that.
Thus, the reflex routes may be traced which include a deformed
proprioceptive apparatus, ways of deep sensibility, spinal segmental
apparatus and structures of truncus cerebri, efferent descending
tracts (reticulospinal, rubrospinal, pyramidal) anterior horn of the
spinal cord, motoneuron with deformed territory of the motor unit.
The stable pathologic state (N.P.Bekhterev et al., 1978) of this
system signifies a completion of peripheric determinant structure
development which is generated by M.T.P. Activation of this system is
possible due to extended zone of its activity with formation of new
generators and stability of pathologic processes whereas the
effectiveness of the inhibitory functions is decreased.
A special place in M.T.P. pathogenesis is occupied by tenderness
of an indispensable element of the above phenomena. The development
of local pain and muscular tension one should regard as an
interrelated process. Disturbance in the correlation of
proprioceptive and extraceptive impulsation (absence of impulse
inhibition of nociceptive modality due to decreased afferentation of
the proprioceptive nature) in the postesior horn region is known to
be responsible for feeling of pain (R.Melzack at. al., 1965).
Imbalance in proprioceptive impulsation while the extraceptive
impulsation level is constant (afferentation of the nociceptive
nature may be partly increased) makes conditions for generation of
pain potentials. From the point of view of determinant structure
functioning the evidance of pain syndrome may be explained by the
development of a hyperactive structure in the posterior horn region
where the decrease of presynaptic impulse inhibition coming from
M.T.P. is surmised.
The assumption about the biologically active substances produced
in the M.T.P. region which are responsible for generation of local
tenderness proves to be not very convincing from the point of view of
prompt disapearance of tenderness during manual therapy (see
further). The analgesic effect thus achieved within some seconds with
simultaneous myorelaxation can not be due to a normalization of the
biochemical content in the M.T.P zone. Naturally, microcirculation
and metabolism disorders as component of any long muscular tension
may occur but only as secondary and not obligatory phenomena.
Possible distrophic changes with sclerosis (fibrosis) as we see it,
in the muscular activity under the above conditions are extremely
rare, which is confirmed by clinical observations. The more so for
these changes are detected morphologically more seldom than it is
diagnosed by palpatory assessment.
In this diagram the mimic muscle contracture occupies a separate
place. Though the clinical M.T.P. manifestation in the sceletal
musculature and mimic muscles seem to be unlike the pathogenesis of
their development has much in common. The characteristic features of
these mimic muscles have a significant influence on the development
and clinical M.T.P. manifestations. They are as follows:
1) the mimic muscles are hypodermic and compose an anatomical
structure as a symplast, having no fascial intermuscular septa
(resembling somehow of the myocardium);
2) they have no statistic functions;
3) the ratio of the muscle efferent innervation is high, these
muscles are exact and quick;
4) the mimic muscles have a high sensibility to acetylcholine.
To fully understand the mechanism of the initial stages of
contracture one should emphasize two more things necessary to make
the likelihood of secondary contracture very high. This is first of
all a mild (of median degree) affection of the nerve - efferent tract
preservation, though a defective one; second, it is an evidence of
pain phenomena accompanying facial nerve neuropathy over the whole
period of time including the antecedent period (precursors).
Taking into account all this and the above considerations
concerning M.T.P pathogenesis of the skeletal muscles, the
development of the secondary contracture of the mimic muscles may be
seen in the following way.
It is stated that at the earlier stages of impairment of facial
nerve hypertonicity of the mimic muscles is detected in all cases and
at any degree of mimic muscle lesion (G.A.Ivanichev, 1982, 1985). The
formation of trigger points one should relate to a variety of
contributing factors (increased sensibility of denervated muscles to
acetylcholine, release of biologically active substances as a result
of pain syndrome, more intense contractile activities of denervated
muscles), which result in the development of palpable indurations in
the mimic musculature. They may be revealed early - in 3-4 days. They
are characterized by marked tenderness during muscle stretching,
though they may not be revealed by palpation alone.
When nerve affection is mild and the functions can be well
restored, the hypertonicities thus developed can have involution and
the mimic musculature has all functions restored without a defect. In
severe nerve affection both the developed hypertonicity and the
affected muscles rapidly undergo all degenerative changes resulting
in the eventual death of the muscles.
In moderately severe nerve affections there may be total complex
of phenomena when nerve repair is rather late as compared to the
processes occuring in muscles. During partial denervation when the
muscle has a prolonged deficiency in stimulation, any exogenic (from
the face skin) as well as endogenic effect exerted (the humoral
medium etc) may be inadequate. Increased sensibility of denervated
muscles to acetylcholine as evidenced by tonomotor effect is an
indication of raised exitability in M.T.P. Electromyographically it
is evident by a rhythmic activity of certain muscular portions,
observed by many authers in needle electrode technique. This activity
is manifested by potential discharges 3-4 ms long with intervals
between them of 1,2 - 2 s. Irritation of the facial nerve trunk
stimulates these potentials for a long period of time (5-6 s). They
may be provoked by mechanical irritations of muscles also.
In this connection it should be noted that there is so caled
secondary contraction of a resting muscle overlaying a contracting
one (I.S.Beritov, 1947). Transmission of stimulation from one muscle
to another easily occurs when there is a slight insulator between
them. A denervated mimic symplast may be an ideal medium in this
respect. The area of muscle contraction thus appearing, which is
active in relation to the neighbouring ones, causes currents of
action in these neighbouring muscles, while relaxation of this
contraction occurs slowly and is incomplete due to passive
generators. This is contributed by relative autonomy of a contractile
process due to deficiency of the efferent control under conditions of
invariable proprioceptive impulsation. Generated by this process a
continuous current called contractural (I.S.Beritov, 1947) can by
itself support a contractile process and prolong the time of muscle
relaxation. Often erroneously administered proserin or electrical
procedures (taking into account an increased muscle excitability to
acetylcholine and tendency to contractile reactions) are able to
maintain this process. Thus, supported over a long period of time a
contractile process in the isolated muscular groups signifies M.T.P.
developments in the mimic musculature as a functional substrate of
secondary contracture.
The statement that a neural scar at the site of lession is able
to "mix" impulses and not deliver them to a precise addressee's
place, producing contracture (A.K.Popov, 1968) is not confirmed
electromyographically: transmission of the nerve impulse in the
formed scar is physiologically ridiculous. It is stated that mixing
of impulses in the affected nerve is possible to occur only over a
short period of time at the beginning of attack when there is an area
of the demyelinized nerve (G.A.Ivanichev, 1980; Ja.B. Yudelson,
1982). Further re- and hypermyelinization of the zones of the
affected nerve cancels this completely as a pathogenic factor
(N.N.Bogolepov et al., 1974).
Even if we assume that such probability exists then "at the
moment when all fibres growing along the peripheral fascial tubes are
growing into the peripheral organs and establish the organ synapses,
immediately some relations are established between the organ and the
central apparatus according to the type of functional loads"
(P.K.Anokhin, 1975). Admitting the existance of such mechanism we
must expect functional restoration of the mimic muscles with no
complications at all. But in our case regenerating nerve is growing
into a changed, qualitativly special work organ - hypertonicity. The
qualitative characteristics of hypertonicity have been already
mentioned by us: imbalanced proprioceptive afferentation, distortion
of Motor Units terminals territories, reduced intensity of inhibitory
processes, the high level of exitability.
Then, how do synkineses arise?
In none of the skeletal muscles which has M.T.P. or other
pathological elements, synkinesis does not arise.Muscle contraction
even under these conditions is an isolated one without participation
of the neighbouring muscles. Muscle synkineses are not observed even
in such severe lesions as polymyositis. The assumption that the
neural scar is responsible for synkineses turned out not to be true.
The participation of the facial nerve nucleus in synkineses
generation due to a pathologic relationship between the neuron groups
were not confirmed clinically or electrophysiologically. A variety of
affected bodies of scull motoneurons and spinal neurons are known
which are clinically and anatomically verified when no synkineses
occurred. In this connection only considerations concerning
peculiarities of the mimic musculature itself allows to clearly
understand this phenomenon.
As it was already reported the mimic muscles contain no fascial
elements and intertwine with the facial skin. The coefficient of
innervation is higher than in the skeletal muscles. It is due to
these peculiarities that a quick and precise mimic muscles play may
occur in displaying emotions.
The same properties of the mimic muscles are underlying
mechanisms of generating pathologic movements - synkineses. In the
absence of a reliable insulator between the deformed fascicles and
fibers, the abundance of intertissue liquid around the denervated
tissue and dystrophic changes of sarcolemma, endo- and perimysium,
create conditions for transmission of the nervous impulse from one
muscular fiber to a neighbouring one. In other words "an artificial
synapse" develops between the muscles and not at the site of nerve
lesion. The intermuscular transmission of nerve impulses may be
possible under normal conditions too (W.Trojaborg, 1977)
While regenerating fibers are growing into the normal muscle and
M.T.P. a muscular conglomerate is created with differently
functioning zones approaching each other. Even the junctions of the
contiguous parts of fibers may be possible. It is due to this defect
that the normal relationship between the center and periphery
according to the type of functional adjustment is impossible. Any
impulse transmitted from the center will produce a stereotyped motor
effect as more or less synchronous contractions of the mimic muscles
(the impulse simultaneously involves different by their function and
far from each other located muscles). Assuming the existance of such
mechanism allows to understand the distribution of stereotyped
synkineses by a clinical feature-palpebro-labial, oculo-zigomatic
etc.
As it was already mentioned, hypertonicity arises in the most
strong and thick parts of the muscle. In the mimic muscles these
portions occupy the sites of their fixation with bones along the
basic muscles. Very often it is difficult to see what certain muscles
these points of fixation belong to. The existence of intertwinings,
zones of muscle overlapping at M.T.P. site creates conditions for
cross transmission of a motor impulse to muscles far located from
each other and different by their functions for example from a
zygomatic to an orbicular muscle and vice versa. In primary (active)
muscle excitation in the region of mouth circumference (grinning)
impulses go upward to be transferred then in the region of maxillary
puberosity to the muscles of the upper part of the face. On the
contrary in screwing up one's eyes impulse transmission is possible
in the zone where zygomatic muscles raising the mouth angle and cheek
muscles are approaching each other. Otherwise a contractile process,
isolated under normal conditions occurs almost synchronously in
different by their functions muscles. This explains a stereotype way
and invariability of synkineses not only in one particular patient
but in all patients with contractures. M.T.P. is a generator of
synkineses in any localization if the reflex ring is preserved with
reduced threshold of excitability of the total neuromotor system. In
these cases one may assume the appearance of a peculiar "pace maker"
or an ectopic generator of excitability in the mimic musculature
which reminds of heterotopic pace makers in the affected myocardium.
The activity of the latter is known to be very high.
The participation of limbico-reticulo complex in this scheme
seems to be delayed (Ja.B.Yudelson, 1982). The participation of these
systems at the stage of a formed determinant structure in the
trigeminal facial nerve system is precisely demonstrated by relief
from reflex reactions, i.e. a decreased supraspinal inhibitory
control. The dysfunction of this section of the brain is largely
responsible for an emotional colouring of the main clinical evidences
of contracture - mimic musculature is a main manifestation of the
functional state of the limbic brain.